Homeowners Knowledge Hub

Heating System Comparisons

Honest comparisons of running costs, comfort, disruption and suitability for different property types.

Comparisons between heating systems are usually sold rather than explained. These guides set heat pumps against gas, oil, LPG and direct electric on the terms that actually matter to a household: running cost, comfort, disruption and suitability.

Where heat pumps compare well

Properties currently heated by oil or LPG tend to show the strongest case, which is why the scheme offers an uplifted grant for eligible off-gas-grid properties replacing those fuels. Running costs for oil and LPG are volatile and delivery is a recurring nuisance.

Where the case is harder

A property on mains gas with a recently installed, efficient boiler and poor insulation presents a weaker case. That does not make it impossible, but it does mean the numbers deserve scrutiny rather than enthusiasm.

What we will not do

We will not publish running-cost comparisons dressed up as precision. Actual costs depend on your tariff, your usage, your building fabric and the flow temperature your system runs at. Anyone quoting a single national savings figure is guessing.

For the funding side of the comparison, see Boiler Upgrade Scheme.

Articles in Heating System Comparisons

Articles for this topic are in preparation. In the meantime, the hub index lists what is available.

Check your heating grant options

Tell us about your property and we shall introduce you to a single MCS-certified installer covering your area. Free to enquire, and never shared with more than one company.

Check your heating grant options